Whelan: England Women’s diversity problem must be tackled

Former England and Brighton defender Fern Whelan believes tackling the Lionesses’ diversity problem is essential in ensuring Black girls do not drop out of football.

Sarina Wiegman’s Euro 2022-winning squad featured just three Black or mixed-heritage players in Jess Carter, Nikita Parris and Demi Stokes, none of whom were handed significant playing time.

Whelan, the Professional Footballers’ Association’s first women’s football EDI executive, has seen first-hand what a lack of visible familiar faces can mean for a girl with Euro or World Cup aspirations of her own.

Speaking at a Parliamentary Women and Equalities Committee session, Whelan said: “[Some] players might come into the system, maybe looking at football and thinking, ‘you know, I can’t connect with any of those players in that Euros Lionesses team because they’re predominately white and I’m a Black girl, and I don’t see that I can achieve anything in football’.

“I spoke to a young girl recently, she was in an Arsenal academy. And she basically just said, ‘look, everybody above me was white and there was a sea of people I couldn’t connect with, so I stopped playing and I didn’t see it was for me’.

“She must have been talented. She was playing at Arsenal at under-16 level, so we don’t want that to be the case over the next five, 10 years.

“We have these players in elite positions, your Demi Stokes, your Nikita Parris, these types of players. [They can see them and think], ‘I can connect with them. I can see their story, and I think there’s an avenue for me in that’.”

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Sheffield United’s Courtney Sweetman-Kirk has called for urgent action to address the lack of diversity within the women’s game

Beth Mead, one of the most recognisable faces of England’s Euro 2022 victory, recently came under scrutiny for controversial comments relating to the lack of diversity in the Lionesses’ squad, telling The Guardian: “I think it’s completely coincidental. We put out our best 11 [at England] and you don’t think of anyone’s race or anything like that. I think that’s more an outsider’s perspective.”

The Arsenal forward has since suggested her words were taken out of context and reiterated her commitment to growing representation within the game. Mead also had a private chat with former Gunner and pundit Ian Wright about the issue.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Beth Mead has defended herself over comments in an interview she gave to The Guardian in which she was quoted as calling the lack of diversity in the Lionesses squad ‘a coincidence’

Wright and former Lioness Eniola Aluko have attempted to redirect the ensuing public debate back to systemic issues requiring a full ecosystem focus.

One frequently cited factor is geography, leading to some cases where transport, or a lack thereof, trumps talent when it comes to accessing training hubs and academies often located outside of city centres.

“I personally went through, when I was playing at a club, I was getting a lift from my actual manager,” recalled Whelan. “There were three players, all of us in a minibus, all Black. And at that point, we physically couldn’t get to training. If I hadn’t have had people who would step forward for me and say ‘look I’ll pick you up, I’ll then go pick up this player, then we’ll go get another one’, that access is a massive thing.”

One of those three players was Parris.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

England international Ella Toone says ‘a lot more can be done’ to encourage diversity within the English game

The FA hopes its new Emerging Talent Centres (ETCs), replacing 30 Regional Talent Centres, will open the door to more girls. In July, the association announced the first 60 licenses allocated to the programme, backed by £1.75m from the Premier League and aimed at girls aged eight to 16. Licences were allocated on a regional basis to cover a wider breadth of the country.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Former Leicester defender and coach Holly Morgan says more needs to be done to address the lack of diversity in the women’s game

More licenses could still be granted, with the new provision, said the FA, set to raise the number of young female players involved in its programmes from 1722 to over 4200 by the end of the 2023/24 season. Licensees range from clubs to associations, trusts and foundations.

Whelan was pleased to see the progress but warned: “We would potentially need more still. I think access will still be a barrier.

“The strides are being made, but I think we definitely need to look at that, because people should not be excluded from playing football, especially at such a young age. We want to widen the talent pool, we don’t want to narrow it at any point.”


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *